Beat softened cream cheese, strawberry preserves, powdered sugar, and vanilla in a bowl until smooth.
Spread cream cheese mixture evenly over one side of four bread slices.
Arrange thinly sliced fresh strawberries in single layer over cream cheese spread.
Top with remaining bread slices to create four sandwiches.
Press sandwiches gently to adhere bread to filling.
Cut each sandwich into heart shapes using a three-inch heart cookie cutter.
Discard bread crusts or reserve crusts for homemade breadcrumbs.
Arrange heart tea sandwiches on serving trays and serve immediately.